Saints Row 4 vs GTA 5: A Clash of Open World Titans

GTA, as the popularising influence and poster child of the open world crime-themed third person action game, casts a long shadow. Not, apparently, long enough to intimidate the rival Saint’s Row franchise, the fourth installment of which will be launching a few weeks before the GTA juggernaut is set to hit.

Distinctive Gameplay Styles

In Volition producer Jim Boone’s own words, “the thing we feel good about in general is that we’re such a different game to what they are. If we were stylistically similar to the first Saints Row, I’d be horrified right now. Saints Row the Third came out the same time as Assassin’s Creed, but the games are so different in terms of what they do.”

Boone’s confidence stems from the unique identity that Saints Row has carved out for itself over the years. While GTA focuses on a more grounded, albeit exaggerated, depiction of crime and urban life, Saints Row has embraced a more fantastical and over-the-top approach. This distinction is evident in the gameplay mechanics, storylines, and overall tone of the games. For instance, Saints Row 4 introduces superpowers and alien invasions, elements that are far removed from the more realistic setting of GTA.

The Evolution of Open World Games

“The genre’s matured enough where you can have all these different styles and still be an open world game and be different,” Boone explained. “So I look at GTA 5 and think there’s this massive game coming out, but I don’t think with our superpowers and alien invasions that no-one will be comparing us to them.”

Boone’s statement highlights the evolution of the open world genre. In its early days, open world games were often compared directly to each other, with little room for variation in style and theme. However, as the genre has matured, developers have found ways to innovate and differentiate their games. This has led to a diverse range of open world experiences, from the historical settings of Assassin’s Creed to the post-apocalyptic landscapes of Fallout.

Saints Row 4’s release timing, just weeks before GTA 5, could have been a cause for concern. However, the distinctiveness of the two games means that they cater to different audiences and offer unique experiences. While GTA 5 promises a sprawling, detailed world with a focus on narrative and realism, Saints Row 4 offers a more whimsical and chaotic experience, filled with humor and absurdity.

Moreover, the success of both franchises demonstrates the broad appeal of the open world genre. Players are not limited to a single type of experience; they can enjoy the gritty realism of GTA and the outrageous fun of Saints Row. This diversity is a testament to the creativity and innovation of game developers, who continue to push the boundaries of what open world games can be.

In conclusion, while GTA may cast a long shadow, it is not one that Saints Row 4 needs to fear. The two games, though similar in their open world structure, offer vastly different experiences. This variety enriches the gaming landscape, providing players with a wealth of options to explore and enjoy.

Source Eurogamer