As far as Double Fine games go, Brutal Legend was probably the only outright dysfunctional one. Most Double Fine games (apart from Psychonauts) are mechanically simple and rely on humor and personality in spades to carry them through. Brutal Legend was simply broken, despite succeeding wildly in ticking the humor and story boxes.
The Unique Blend of Action and RTS
Brutal Legend attempted to blend action-adventure gameplay with real-time strategy (RTS) elements, a combination that was ambitious but ultimately flawed in execution. The game’s protagonist, Eddie Riggs, voiced by Jack Black, navigates a heavy metal-inspired world filled with fantastical creatures and epic battles. While the narrative and voice acting were top-notch, the gameplay mechanics often felt disjointed. The transition between action sequences and RTS segments was jarring, leaving players confused and frustrated. The RTS elements, in particular, were criticized for being underdeveloped and difficult to manage, especially during intense battles.
Potential for a Revamped Version
Which is why it would be amazing to see Tim Schafer revisit the game and try to nail down the original vision. Maybe run some shears through those confusing tangles of action and RTS. And that’s exactly what might happen if the game does well on PC.
“It’s actually been fun to continue work on it,” Tim Schafer said. “I mean, we have a wishlist from when we made this version. But since we are a small developer publishing it ourselves, we have to go with the best version we can make and then hope it’s successful so we can add more.”
The potential for a revamped version of Brutal Legend is exciting for fans who appreciated the game’s unique aesthetic and humor but were disappointed by its gameplay issues. A successful PC release could provide the necessary funding and motivation for Double Fine to address these shortcomings. Enhancements could include more intuitive controls, refined RTS mechanics, and additional content that expands on the game’s rich lore and characters.
Moreover, the PC platform offers opportunities for modding, which could allow the community to contribute to the game’s improvement. User-generated content could introduce new missions, characters, and even gameplay mechanics, further enriching the Brutal Legend experience.
Community and Critical Reception
Despite its flaws, Brutal Legend has maintained a cult following over the years. The game’s unique blend of humor, music, and storytelling has resonated with players who appreciate its originality. The soundtrack, featuring iconic heavy metal tracks, adds to the game’s immersive atmosphere and has been praised as one of the best in video game history.
Critically, Brutal Legend received mixed reviews. While the narrative and artistic direction were lauded, the gameplay mechanics were a point of contention. Some reviewers appreciated the game’s ambition, while others felt that it failed to deliver a cohesive experience. However, the game’s charm and personality have allowed it to endure in the hearts of many gamers.
Looking Forward
The possibility of a revamped Brutal Legend is a tantalizing prospect. With advancements in technology and game design, Double Fine has the opportunity to create a version of the game that lives up to its original vision. By addressing the gameplay issues and building on the game’s strengths, Tim Schafer and his team could deliver a truly exceptional experience.
In conclusion, Brutal Legend remains a fascinating entry in Double Fine’s portfolio. Its unique blend of humor, music, and storytelling set it apart, even if its gameplay mechanics left much to be desired. A successful PC release could pave the way for a revamped version that realizes the game’s full potential, offering both old fans and new players a chance to experience the world of Brutal Legend in all its glory.
Source Rock, Paper, Shotgun
Latest Geeky Gadgets Deals
Disclosure: Some of our articles include affiliate links. If you buy something through one of these links, Geeky Gadgets may earn an affiliate commission. Learn about our Disclosure Policy.
